Everton will need to decide on the future of midfielder Carlos Alcaraz before the January transfer window, according to former senior Everton scout Bryan King, who spoke exclusively to Football Insider. The 23-year-old joined Everton permanently from Flamengo in the summer of 2025 and is set to be out of contract at the end of the season, meaning he can sign a pre-contract agreement in January.
Limited role under Moyes
Football Insider reports that Alcaraz has been limited to brief appearances off the bench under David Moyes this season. He did score against Wolves in September, when he was given slightly more opportunity in the Carabao Cup. According to the report, Monday’s trip to Brentford could be a key test of the manager’s view of the Argentine.
The report also notes that Alcaraz scored twice and provided an assist in a friendly against Derby County during the international break. Football Insider frames this as a performance that gives him little further room to impress his manager.
Expert view on the situation
King told Football Insider that the difficulty for Moyes is that only 11 players can start, and the players being selected are performing. He said it was nice to have a player like Alcaraz available when needed, adding that he did not believe the manager was missing a trick. King also suggested that the agent and player would not be happy if Alcaraz remains out of the side, and that a new contract must be offered before or in January, otherwise he could leave as a free agent.
These comments are the view of one commentator as reported by Football Insider and have not been independently confirmed. No new contract offer or agreement has been reported in the supplied material.
What comes next
Football Insider also quotes Alcaraz from February saying he has been treated well at the club and decided to stay, and that he hopes to remain at Everton for more years. The coming months will determine whether a new deal is agreed or whether the midfielder’s contract situation moves in another direction. Readers can follow Football Maza for further updates on Everton’s transfer position.





