The Premier League has confirmed that Sam Barrott will referee Liverpool’s home meeting with Manchester United at Anfield on Sunday, with John Brooks overseeing VAR duties, according to a report from Football FanCast. The appointment has already drawn criticism from former PGMOL chief Keith Hackett, who questioned the selection process overseen by Howard Webb.
Frequency of appointments questioned
Football FanCast reports that Barrott has already refereed two Liverpool home matches this season. Sunday’s fixture would be his third assignment at Anfield in just six Premier League fixtures. Hackett was complimentary about Barrott’s ability, but his comments, as reported by Football FanCast, suggest frustration with how often the official is appointed to Liverpool home games.
Context for both clubs
Both sides are under pressure. Liverpool sit fourth in the Premier League but have had a poor record at Anfield this season, while Manchester United arrive with Mauricio Pochettino in charge for the first time after replacing Michael Carrick. United are also dealing with injury doubts, including Benjamin Sesko, Luke Shaw and Marcus Rashford, while Liverpool remain without Hugo Ekitike, Giovanni Leoni and Conor Bradley, with Jeremie Frimpong and Ryan Gravenberch also doubtful.
Barrott’s record and past controversies
According to the report, Barrott has officiated 65 Premier League matches and Liverpool remain unbeaten in four league matches he has refereed. The article also recalls that he awarded Nottingham Forest a penalty in their 2-2 draw at Anfield, which the Premier League’s independent Key Match Incidents Panel later ruled should not have been given, although it supported VAR’s decision not to intervene. Barrott was also the referee when James Tarkowski avoided a red card in Liverpool’s 2024/25 meeting with Everton, a missed VAR intervention the panel later identified.
The report states that the panel has identified 14 errors across Barrott’s 65 appointments, seven of them on-field or second-yellow-card mistakes. It also notes that neither club’s historical results under Barrott provide evidence of refereeing bias. This is a single-source summary and has not been independently verified.
Football Maza will continue to track the officiating arrangements and any response from the Premier League ahead of kick-off.





