Messi Throw-In Incident Against Tapia Sparks Red Card Debate in MLS Playoff Clash

Lionel Messi throw-in incident: Lionel Messi throw-in incident drew criticism from Columbus Crew coach Laurent Courtois, who said the Inter Miami forward deserved a red card rather than a yellow card, according to World Soccer Talk and Football Maza coverage.

Lionel Messi’s first-half confrontation with Columbus Crew forward Gonzalo Tapia has become the main talking point of Inter Miami’s MLS Cup playoff opener, according to a report from World Soccer Talk. The incident, which came during a difficult evening for the defending champions, has also revived comparisons with Cristiano Ronaldo’s 2024 dismissal in Saudi Arabia.

Inter Miami entered its first-round meeting with Columbus on Saturday hoping to begin its title defence with a win. Messi had received the MLS Golden Boot before kick-off, but the match soon turned against the hosts. Columbus took the lead in the ninth minute from a Tapia penalty after goalkeeper Dayne St. Clair brought him down in the area. Miami was then reduced to 10 men in the 36th minute when Gonzalo Lujan received a second yellow card.

The Messi and Tapia incident

During first-half stoppage time, Messi and Tapia became involved in an argument near the touchline. The report says Tapia stood close to Messi as he tried to take a quick throw-in and appeared to obstruct the restart. Messi then pushed the ball into Tapia’s face and threw it towards his opponent’s head from close range. Tapia went down, prompting protests from Columbus players.

Referee Allen Chapman showed both players a yellow card, allowing Messi to stay on the pitch. Columbus head coach Laurent Courtois said after the match that Messi deserved more than a yellow card. Chapman later told a pool reporter that the force used was negligible and did not reach the level of violent conduct.

Disciplinary standard under debate

World Soccer Talk notes that Major League Soccer’s competition guidelines define violent conduct as the use of excessive force or brutality when a player is not challenging for the ball. The Athletic refereeing expert Graham Scott is reported to have argued that a red card would have been the more defensible decision, judging the contact deliberate and excessive. These are the views reported by the publisher; this article has not independently verified the officiating assessments.

Comparison with Ronaldo’s 2024 red card

The article links the incident to Ronaldo’s dismissal for violent conduct in the Saudi Super Cup semi-final against Al-Hilal on April 8, 2024. In that match, Ronaldo became involved in a physical altercation with defender Saud Abdulhamid during a dispute over a throw-in, and Al-Nassr lost 2-1. Fans online have drawn parallels because the trigger in both cases was a contested quick throw-in.

The report also draws a distinction. Messi directed the ball at an opponent’s face from very short range, while Ronaldo made direct physical contact with his body. Under the Laws of the Game, striking or headbutting is typically treated more severely than contact with the ball, although intent and force still matter in each case.

Football Maza will continue to follow whether Major League Soccer reviews the decision, as the publisher report indicates Courtois was asked about a possible review.

Alex Morgan

Alex Morgan covers international football, major European leagues, transfer developments, and match analysis. Focused on delivering accurate, timely, and engaging football coverage for fans worldwide.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Explore Football Maza