Arsenal fans and neutrals are divided over whether Mikel Arteta’s pragmatic approach is worth moving away from the attacking football associated with Arsene Wenger, according to a fan poll reported by Arsenal Insider and drawn from TalkingPoints users.
Trophies versus entertainment
Arsenal Insider notes that Wenger was celebrated for entertaining football during his 22 years in charge, and that Arteta’s side won the Premier League in the 2025/26 season, the club’s first league title since Wenger’s Invincibles of 2003/04. The publication also points out that Wenger won three Premier League titles and seven FA Cup winners’ medals with Arsenal.
According to the report, Arteta has made Arsenal one of the most defensively solid teams in Europe, conceding a league-low 27 goals en route to the 2025/26 title, and winning nine of the opening 10 Premier League games of the 2026/27 season. The article also says rival fans and pundits have accused the side of relying on set-pieces and grinding out 1-0 wins.
What fans said
In a Talk Arsenal post on TalkingPoints cited by Arsenal Insider, many users said they would prefer to watch Wenger’s attacking style. One user was quoted saying Wenger’s team was box office but could also lose heavily on a bad day, while another said Arteta’s football wins matches even if nobody enjoys it.
- Neutral fans quoted in the piece generally favoured Wenger’s entertainment value.
- Several respondents said that, if they supported Arsenal, they would prioritise winning regardless of style.
- One Arsenal supporter quoted in the article said they did not miss being outplayed by bigger sides in the Wenger era.
Head-to-head records
Arsenal Insider’s analysis of Premier League records states that Wenger struggled to beat Manchester United and Liverpool consistently after 2004, and won only three of 15 meetings with Manchester City from 2011 to 2018. The report says Arteta has a stronger recent record against Chelsea and Manchester United, while Manchester City remain his toughest domestic opponent, with two wins and three draws in 12 Premier League games according to the article.
The publication is the source of all these statistics and quotes; the figures have not been independently verified by Football Maza.






