The Premier League’s key match incidents panel has supported referee John Brooks’s decision not to send off Leeds United defender Jayden Bogle during his side’s 1-0 win over Tottenham Hotspur at Elland Road on November 7, according to a report by the Yorkshire Post.
What happened
Bogle caught the back of the ankle of Spurs winger Mathys Tel, forcing the forward out of action. Brooks did not card the challenge, and the video assistant referee (VAR) did not call him over for a review. The Yorkshire Post reports that the decision sparked considerable controversy, with the losing side believing Leeds should have been reduced to 10 men.
The panel’s verdict
The panel reached a split decision on the on-field call. The Yorkshire Post quotes the panel as saying the majority supported the referee’s decision of no red card. The majority considered the contact a clear foul, but felt Bogle was challenging with his right leg and that his left leg came down on Tel’s ankle without the speed, force or intensity required for serious foul play.
According to the panel’s statement as reported, the contact was recklessly made but fell below the threshold for a red card. Two panellists judged the challenge dangerous enough to merit a red card. The panel also backed the decision not to intervene, by a 3-2 margin, because the majority regarded the challenge as reckless rather than a clear and obvious error.
Reaction
The Yorkshire Post reports that Tottenham signalled their intention to appeal the decision. Former Premier League referee Graham Barber, quoted by the publication, said he considered the challenge very poor and said Bogle should have been sent off, arguing it endangered the safety of the opponent, as Tel had to leave the field about five minutes later.
Football Maza has not independently verified the panel’s findings. The details above are drawn from the Yorkshire Post’s report.







