A new retrospective cohort study tracking Spain’s top-flight footballers suggests that returning from anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) surgery does not necessarily restore a player’s previous level or value. According to the research, published in Knee Surgery & Related Research and reported here by Football Maza, 132 ACL injuries across 115 professional players were tracked over 14 seasons, from 2010–2011 to 2023–2024.
High return rate, lasting consequences
The study found that 97.7% of athletes returned to an official matchday squad, with a mean return-to-play time of about 9.1 months. The authors defined return to play as inclusion in a matchday squad, a proxy for medical clearance, rather than actual match participation.
Despite that high rate, the researchers reported that 35.2% of players dropped at least one competitive league level by the first post-injury season, rising to 61.3% by the fifth season.
Playing time and match involvement
According to the publication’s summary of the findings, minutes played per season fell by an average of 46% in the first post-injury season, and players never returned to their pre-injury seasonal minutes. Players also recorded about 21 fewer minutes per appearance in the first and second postoperative seasons. The study additionally reported that 71.9% of cases waited a median of 13.5 days between matchday squad inclusion and competitive minutes.
Market value
The study reported a mean market value reduction of approximately 47.7% by year five, with players aged 30 or older showing particularly marked declines. The authors cautioned that market value is influenced by age, contract status and commercial factors.
Limitations
- The study had no matched uninjured control group, so it cannot establish direct causation.
- Some declines may reflect normal career progression, particularly given a mean age of 26.7 years.
- Market value and playing data came from public databases such as Transfermarkt and BeSoccer.
- Surgical-technique associations were exploratory and described by the researchers as hypothesis-generating.
The researchers, led by V. Montiel and colleagues, concluded that high return-to-play rates may mask broader career consequences and called for continued refinement of rehabilitation and injury-prevention protocols. This report relies on a single published study and the accompanying publisher summary, which has not been independently verified.









