Former Liverpool midfielder Danny Murphy has questioned whether Alex Scott is the right profile for Liverpool’s defensive midfield, according to comments he gave a Romanian outlet that were also reported by the Liverpool Echo and relayed by Dave.Sport.
Murphy said he does not see Scott as a defensive midfielder. He admires the player, who worked under Andoni Iraola at Bournemouth, but questioned whether Scott has the athleticism of elite holding midfielders such as Moisés Caicedo and Declan Rice. In a side that wants to push forward, he argued, the deepest midfielder has to cover a large area of the pitch.
Scott has been linked with Liverpool and Chelsea in a deal that PariuriX, as cited by Dave.Sport, says could cost more than £100m. This is a reported link rather than a confirmed transfer, and no agreement has been announced in the supplied source.
Tactics over personnel
Murphy also said Adam Wharton, whom he described as a more classic defensive midfielder, is not playing particularly well at present. His central argument is that Iraola’s midfield issues are tactical rather than about the individuals involved. He said Liverpool need one of their midfielders, whether Trey Nyoni, Alexis Mac Allister or Ryan Gravenberch, to be more disciplined.
Murphy pointed to Gravenberch’s role as the deepest midfielder during Liverpool’s Premier League-winning season under Arne Slot in 2024-25, and argued he showed the discipline needed in that position. He wants Iraola to return him to the role.
Fitness question
Gravenberch’s availability has limited Iraola’s options. According to the source, the Dutchman missed the trips to Fenerbahçe and Crystal Palace with a fractured heel, and Iraola said before the Palace game that his availability depended on the pain. Whether he is fit will be one of the main selection decisions when Liverpool host Manchester United at 4.30pm on Sunday 22 November, in Mauricio Pochettino’s first game in charge.
Football Maza will follow team news ahead of kick-off. For the latest, see the Premier League coverage in this section.





