Premier League panel says Arsenal should have had penalty against Hull over Havertz incident

Kai Havertz penalty: the Premier League's Key Match Incidents panel says Arsenal should have been awarded a spot kick against Hull, while Coventry were wronged at Everton and Manchester United's late equaliser against Aston Villa was upheld.

The Premier League’s Key Match Incidents (KMI) panel has ruled that Arsenal should have been awarded a penalty in their 1-0 win over Hull at the Emirates on 7 November, according to the round 10 decisions published by the league and reported by Dave.Sport.

Havertz penalty appeal

The panel reviewed two penalty appeals involving Kai Havertz and Hull’s Nobel Mendy. It backed referee Farai Hallam’s decision to play on after a challenge by Mendy in the 12th minute. For the incident in the 42nd minute, the panel unanimously disagreed with the outcome.

The panel said Havertz was already in an offside position, but Mendy held him before he became involved in active play. Under Law 11, a player in an offside position is only penalised once involved in active play, so the foul came first. The Premier League said VAR Michael Oliver was right to recommend a review and that Arsenal should have had a penalty. Martin Odegaard’s 72nd-minute goal meant the decision did not cost Arsenal.

Other round 10 verdicts

  • Everton v Coventry (6 November, 3-1 Everton): the panel unanimously found James Tarkowski held Caleb Yirenkyi’s hair in the 38th minute. It said a penalty and a yellow card should have followed and that VAR should have intervened.
  • Manchester United v Aston Villa: the panel voted 5-0 that Patrick Dorgu’s sixth-minute stoppage-time header, which earned a 4-4 draw, was correctly allowed.
  • Fulham v Newcastle: the panel voted 5-0 to uphold the disallowing of Dan Burn’s 33rd-minute header, citing a hold by Yoane Wissa on Timothy Castagne.
  • Leeds v Tottenham (7 November): the panel split 3-2 on Jayden Bogle’s challenge on Mathys Tel, with three members judging it reckless but below the red-card threshold.

Season context

According to the panel, 78 per cent of on-field decisions in round 10 were correct, below the season average. Across 223 key incidents this season, 85 per cent of on-field decisions have been correct, rising to 97 per cent after VAR. Earlier this month the panel also ruled that Liverpool should have had a penalty against Arsenal.

Football Maza will continue to track the panel’s rulings as they are published.

Ryan Mitchell

Ryan Mitchell covers football transfers, contract developments, emerging talents, and club strategies across international leagues, with an emphasis on verified reports and informed analysis.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Explore Football Maza