The Premier League’s Key Match Incidents (KMI) Panel has ruled that referees made six on-field errors in the last round of games, according to thefalse9.com. That equals the joint-highest number the panel has recorded in a single weekend and is the first time it has logged six since early in the 2023-24 season.
Arsenal and Havertz
The panel’s verdicts, as reported by thefalse9.com, confirm that Arsenal should have had a penalty against Hull. Nobel Mendy held Kai Havertz inside the area in the first half at the Emirates. Referee Farai Hallam was sent to the pitchside monitor, then told the crowd that Havertz had been fouled but that no penalty would be given because he was offside. The panel voted 5:0 that both the referee and VAR got the decision wrong. Martin Odegaard’s 72nd-minute winner meant the error had little bearing on the result.
Crystal Palace and Liverpool
Crystal Palace were awarded a penalty three minutes into stoppage time for Milos Kerkez’s challenge on Dario Osorio, and Eddie Nketiah scored it. The panel was unanimous that the decision was wrong, but also unanimous that it was not a clear and obvious error, so VAR did not intervene. Liverpool won 3-1 with goals from Alexis Mac Allister, Florian Wirtz and Alexander Isak, so the penalty did not change the outcome.
Coventry at Everton
Coventry had two of the six errors go against them in a 3-1 defeat at Everton. The panel unanimously felt VAR should have intervened after Michael Tarkowski held Caleb Yirenkyi’s hair in the first half at 0-0. Thierno Barry’s second goal, in the 61st minute, followed a VAR check for handball; three of five panellists thought it should have been ruled out on the pitch, but all five agreed the available footage was not conclusive.
Other decisions
- Ipswich were wrongly awarded a penalty when Abdoul Ouattara stepped across Lewis Cook, and Bournemouth were wrongly spared a second yellow card for Marcus Tavernier, according to the panel.
- The panel voted 3:2 that Jayden Bogle’s challenge on Mathys Tel did not merit a red card, and 4:1 that Cole Palmer’s fall at Sunderland was rightly not a penalty.
- The panel has logged six missed VAR interventions this season, the same as at this stage last season.
Full details of the verdicts are available from the original report on thefalse9.com. Football Maza will continue to follow Premier League referee decisions as further KMI Panel rulings are published.







