Every season brings loan deals agreed with good intentions, designed to give fringe players minutes, prepare them for reintegration or showcase them for a permanent exit. Some go wrong. According to a Football365 analysis, eight loan moves involving Premier League clubs already look like poor value for the parties involved. Football Maza has reviewed that piece for this roundup.
The article points to Harvey Elliott’s spell at Aston Villa from Liverpool last season as a cautionary example, when Villa’s reluctance to trigger a permanent deal left him sidelined.
Alejandro Garnacho (Aston Villa, on loan from Chelsea)
Football365 reports that Garnacho has yet to start a game for Villa in any competition, has made seven appearances off the bench totalling 95 minutes, and was not in the squad for three of their past four league matches. The publisher also says his loan carries an obligation to buy dependent on appearance criteria.
Promise David (Brighton, on loan from Union SG)
According to the same analysis, David has made four appearances for Brighton, all as a substitute, with two in the Premier League, the most recent in their first game in September. The article says an obligatory purchase clause, reportedly above £20m, is tied to a number of games played.
Altay Bayindir (Celta de Vigo, on loan from Manchester United)
Football365 says Bayindir’s only appearance so far came in a 5-0 Copa del Rey win over Salamanca, with Ionut Radu remaining Celta’s regular starter.
Robinio Vaz (Hull City, on loan from Roma)
The publisher reports Vaz has not started a Premier League match for Hull, his longest appearance has lasted 22 minutes beyond an hour-long EFL Cup start against Sunderland, and he has played an under-21s game this month.
Jean-Matteo Bahoya (Leeds United, on loan from Eintracht Frankfurt)
Football365 says Bahoya has three substitute appearances for Leeds, of one, four and six minutes, and was not in the squad for their last game before the international break. The article quotes Daniel Farke saying Bahoya needs more physicality, better decision making and improved finishing. It also reports that heavier use could oblige Leeds to pay more than £25m.
Evann Guessand (Crystal Palace, on loan from Aston Villa)
According to the analysis, Guessand has not started a Premier League game since his second loan to Palace and has made only three Europa League appearances. The publisher suggests Palace’s intentions on a permanent deal appear unchanged.
Souza (Porto, on loan from Tottenham)
Football365 reports Souza has yet to start in either the league or the Champions League for Porto, though he made a first cup start in late October and played a half of his league debut.
Harvey Elliott (Valencia, on loan from Liverpool)
The publisher says all of Elliott’s La Liga minutes for Valencia have come from the bench, that he was sent off in his sixth league appearance, and that he scored in the Copa del Rey against Tavernes. Valencia have no option or obligation to buy him, according to the article.
Football Maza notes that all details above are drawn from a single publisher account and have not been independently verified. Clubs have not been quoted on these loans in the supplied source beyond the Bahoya comments from Farke.







