The Premier League’s Key Match Incidents (KMI) Panel has ruled that there were six on-field refereeing errors in the last round of games, the joint-highest it has recorded in a single weekend, according to a report published by BBC Sport.
Each week, the five members of the panel assess contentious incidents and vote on whether both the referee and the video assistant referee (VAR) got the decision right. BBC Sport notes that the last time six mistakes were logged was early in the 2023-24 season. The count does not include correct VAR interventions, such as the red card shown to Brentford’s Igor Thiago.
Penalty and offside calls
Several flashpoints drew debate across the weekend. According to BBC Sport, Arsenal were denied a penalty after a VAR review found Kai Havertz offside, although the panel said there was a clear holding action by Hull City’s Nobel Mendy before any offside offence. The panel also judged a Coventry penalty claim, after a hair pull by Everton’s James Tarkowski, an incorrect decision by the referee, with all five members voting that VAR should have intervened.
Liverpool were penalised for a late Crystal Palace penalty, which the panel voted incorrect on the field, though it was not deemed a clear and obvious error for VAR to change. Ipswich’s penalty against Bournemouth was also voted incorrect on the field, while VAR intervention was judged unnecessary.
Red cards and bookings
BBC Sport reports that Leeds United’s Jayden Bogle was not shown a red card after a challenge on Tottenham’s Mathys Tel. The panel voted 3:2 that the on-field decision and the absence of a VAR review were correct, with two members believing the challenge merited a red card. The panel also reportedly considered a potential second yellow card for Bournemouth’s Marcus Tavernier, voting 2:3 that the on-field decision was incorrect.
Context
BBC Sport points out that the KMI Panel matters more in the Premier League than it did in Scotland, where the system was scrapped this summer, because its results feed a merit table that contributes to 50% of referees’ bonus payments. The report also notes that the panel judges decisions against the laws of the game and the league’s expected refereeing standards rather than fan opinion.
At Football Maza, we will keep following how these reviews are reported. The information here comes from the BBC Sport article and has not been independently verified.







